Love That Stopped at the Threshold

Love That Stopped at the Threshold

PLRT Case Report C04

Friend, Protector, Brother… and in This Life, Husband

Namaskar to all the seniors.

This is my fourth case report, and for me the most special so far. Four sessions, nearly thirteen hours, and a struggle the client could not share even with her husband. Madhu, 26, loves her husband. He is caring and never complains; he only says, “Take your time.” Yet a year into their marriage, they had never been physically intimate. Every time, right at the last moment, something inside her pulled her back.

In the sessions, a familiar figure appeared in three lifetimes, in three different relationships, and each time Madhu saw a glimpse of her husband in him. Almost every stage of the Amarantos protocol fell into place, so I am presenting it in detail, with what I learned and some questions for you.

The sessions were in Hindi; this is my translation, kept close to the client’s words. Names of the client and her husband have been changed. (This is a condensed forum edition of my complete 24-section case report.)

Story of Transformation

There Was Love, There Was Belonging… So Why Did She Pull Away Every Time They Came Close?

A year into their marriage, the couple had never been able to come truly close. Madhu loved her husband. She felt at ease with him. Both of them wanted to be closer.

But every time, right at the last moment, something inside pulled her back. There was no quarrel and no fear. Just an unexplained pause that even she could not understand.

Where did that pause come from? The answer came from a place she had never imagined. From a sense of belonging that was very, very old.

After the final session, her own words were: “I don’t want to pull away.”

What happened in those sessions, and how did Madhu come to see her relationship with new eyes? Continue reading to discover the complete 15-Stage PLRT® journey.

Case Map (CM)

══════════════════════

Theme: Intimacy Block
Pain: 9/10 (start), 7/10 (before final session), 1/10 (closure)
DS: Visual | CS: Visual imagery; suggestions built on “see”
Trigger: The moment emotional closeness moves towards physical intimacy
ET: Partial (deep emotional bond with her father; doctor found no physical problem)
HM: The childhood fair, watching the magic show from Papa’s shoulders, “very safe”
SE: The bond of Milda and Tabaka, and the promise to stay together in every life
KMF / CF: KMF: HM, Pre-Natal, PL1, then through the affect bridge of grief to PL2, PL3, PD and LBL
PL1: A girl in a rural school; the friend who cared for her like an elder brother died of illness
PL2: A slave girl in an Arab land; the buyer freed her and treated her like a human being; he was killed by robbers, and she died of hunger and thirst
PL3: Tribal girl Milda; her brother Tabaka protected her; she died in his lap, taking his promise for every life
PD: After PL2: pink sky, rainbows, “as if I have come back home”. After PL3: detached, yet an ache of separation remained
LBL: “New relationships are not copies of the past… every new journey brings a new role”
CO: The protector-brother relational template and the promise across lives (hypothesis)
Res: Experienced her husband as her husband in this life; the old role allowed to be complete
PHS: “What was is complete in its own place. What is may be lived just as it is.”
Outcome: Distress 7 to 1 in the final session; no urge to pull away in the intimacy imagery
FU: Not Documented

══════════════════════

1. Case Overview

Client: Madhu (name changed), 26, female, married about one year, media professional
Theme: Intimacy Block | HR: 9/10 | VAK: 8/4/3 (predominantly Visual) | Eye Roll: 2+1
Distress: 9/10 (first session), 7/10 (start of final session)
Sessions: 4 (2 hr 30 min, 3 hr 10 min, 3 hr 14 min, 3 hr 50 min)
Clinical impression: An emotionally connected, cooperative client. The difficulty did not seem to come from a lack of love; it appeared at one very specific moment. My own assessment, not a formal diagnosis.

2. Presenting Concern, Theme and Safety

The couple has never been physically intimate. Madhu likes her husband, feels close to him, and both want intimacy. In her words: “Everything is fine… it feels good… but when we start getting really close, I suddenly feel like pulling away.” She also said her father has had a deep emotional influence on her, and that she has kept looking for a father-like presence in others.

In the pre-talk she said: “My marriage was arranged by our families, but with both our consent. He was my senior in college… He is caring and loving. He never complains; he says, ‘Take your time.’ I feel guilty. I can’t even tell anyone. I even went to a doctor secretly, and nothing was found wrong. I don’t feel physical attraction towards my husband, but I do have sexual desire. It is a problem I can see no solution to.”

Theme: Intimacy Block, agreed with the client in Session 2 (Stage 8). It names the block at one threshold: the move from emotional closeness to physical intimacy. No “cause” was set in advance; the intention was to see what lay beneath the urge to pull away.

Safety Gate: No psychosis, dissociation or self-harm risk; normal physical health; no alcohol, substances or medication; no painful past experience related to intimacy (as reported by the client); doctor found no physical problem; written consent given.

3. Protocol

All 15 stages were completed. Sessions 1 and 2: introduction, observing non-verbals (client relaxed), pre-talk, written contract, assessment, history taking and theme finalisation. Before induction: video and checklist. Sessions 3 and 4: Dave Elman induction, visualisation, regression, integration and closure. Report and recommendations were sent afterwards. The session moved in its own natural flow; the client’s experience was not pulled into a fixed sequence.

4. Session Transcript (Final Session)

Beginning

(By the fourth session I had a clear picture of the problem. Madhu was not afraid of her husband. She was not angry with him either. There was no conflict in the relationship. She liked being near him. The difficulty came at one very particular moment.)
C: Until we become close, everything is fine.
T: And after that?
(Pause)
C: Suddenly I feel like pulling away.
(I did not interpret this answer.)
T: Today we will simply follow this feeling. We won’t try to change it. We will just see where it takes you.

[HM 1] The Childhood Fair

(After Dave Elman induction and deepening)
T: Now move towards a time in your life… where you find yourself surrounded by happiness… where there is joy… peace… You don’t need to search for anything… whatever memory comes naturally, simply watch it.
(A long pause. A faint smile on her face.)
C: I am little.
T: Where are you?
C: I am at the village fair.
(The client described a crowded village fair: lights, people, sounds, and a magic show in the street, which she could not see because of the crowd.)
C: I can’t see it.

T:…Okay, then?

C: I tell Papa.
C: Papa has put me up on his shoulders.
T: Can you see the magic now?
C: Yes… very clearly.
T: How does it feel right now?
C: It’s so much fun.
T: Feel this happiness… and the feeling of being with Papa too.
(Silence for a while)
T: How does it feel to be with Papa?
C: Very safe.
(I did not interpret this word, and let the client stay in the same memory.)

[Pre-Natal] The Experience in the Womb

T: Keeping this feeling with you… go further back in your life… as far as your experience naturally takes you… towards the time… when you were in your mother’s womb.
(Silence)
C: I am inside.
T: How does it feel?
C: Calm and warm.
(Her facial expression changed)
C: I can hear a voice.
T: Just listen to that voice.
(Pause)
C: It’s Papa’s voice.
T: How do you feel with that voice?
C: Good.
C: It feels like… he is outside, but he is close to me.
(I had not suggested whose voice it was.)

[PL1] The Rural School

(The client saw herself as a little girl in a rural school. A dusty playground, a crowd of children, a kabaddi match. She kept losing, people were laughing, and some children were jeering.)
T: What is happening now?
C: I am losing.
T: How does it feel?
C: Very bad.
T: Why so bad… it’s only a game?
C: Everyone is making fun of me…
T: So is no one on your side?
C: No one… except that one boy…
C: When I fell… and people laughed… he was the only one… who said, Hey, don’t lose heart… you can do it.
T: Do you know that boy?
C: I don’t know… but he feels familiar.

T:…Familiar?

T: Can you tell me something more about this familiarity?
(Silence for a while)
C: He is someone of my own…
T: Okay, someone of your own…
T: Does this familiarity have any connection with your present life?
C: Yes, perhaps…
T: Would you like to tell me anything more about it?
C: He looks like my husband…
(The client went on to say that the two of them are now friends. They study in the same school. The boy always looks after her like an elder brother and always encourages her. She trusts him deeply.)
T: As I count from three to one… we will move to the most significant event of this life… (count down)
C: (a faint, tearful voice)… he is gone
T: Where has he gone?
C: He was ill… he is gone… very… far away.
T: What are you feeling?

C:…I can’t get over the grief of his going…

T: Sometimes seeing yourself from a distance brings relief… try to look at this painful situation like a spectator…
T: Are you still as sad as before?
C: No… I feel the sadness, but not like before
T: Take three deep breaths and watch the restlessness inside you leave

T:…If you wish, you can stay with this feeling for a while

(A long silence. No questions, no answers.)
T: Grief is a bridge… across which our memories travel… Let us see… whether this feeling of losing someone dear is opening another page of life… As I count from three to one… you will find yourself in a new dimension of time (three… two… one)… the first scene… the first experience
C: Terrible heat… sand all around… a caravan of camels…

[PL2] The Stranger Who Set Her Free

(The client found herself in an Arab land as a young slave woman, held in bondage. Frightened and exhausted.)
T: Who is with you?
C: No one…
T: Where are you right now?
C: I am in a slave market… everyone is being sold for dinars…
T: What are you doing?
C: Waiting to be sold…
(She was silent for a while)
C: A man is bargaining for me
T: Do you know him?
C: No.
(The man paid the agreed price, freed her, and set off with her towards his home or settlement. She rode a camel with the caravan. The man who had bought her rode the same camel.)
T: What are you feeling right now?
C: I don’t know… but I feel safe with him…

C:…as if he is someone of my own…

T: Someone of your own… can you see the one who helped you?
C: Yes, I have looked at him, secretly…
T: Is he looking at you too?
C: Yes… there is love for me in his eyes

T:…Anything else… you would like to share?

C: His eyes are exactly like… Tarun’s (Madhu’s husband’s name)…
T: Okay, like Tarun’s… alright… anything more you would like to tell me about this person?
C: It feels… as if I have a long bond with him… though I have never met him before… the sun is right overhead… he is giving me water with his own hands… there are tears in my eyes… for the first time in my life someone has treated me like a human being…
(Suddenly Madhu’s voice rises.)
C: An attack… a fierce attack…
C: Some people have attacked us…
T: Who are they?
C: They have swords in their hands… and their faces are masked…
T: Is everyone safe?
C: They have all been killed, one by one… he too…
T: Is the fighting still going on?
C: The robbers have gone… I am lying wounded on a sand dune…
(Madhu then added that there was no one around. The robbers had taken the camels and the goods. A few companions had fled to save their lives. She was overcome by hunger and thirst, and was now waiting for death.)
T: The end of life is not the end of the journey… as I count from three to one… you will find yourself outside the body (count down)

[PD] After PL2

C: (silent for a while)… no pain now… no restlessness… my body is lying below, dead… and I am up in the sky…
T: Is there anything there… that feels different?
C: I can’t feel anything here… I can only feel my own presence… the sunlight here has no heat… the sky is completely pink… I can see many rainbows all around me… it feels as if I have come back home… I can’t see anyone here… but it feels as if I am among many people…
T: Of what just happened to you… is any part, any experience, still with you right now?
C: A slight ache of losing that stranger who helped me has stayed somewhere inside… like a splinter
T: Is this feeling troubling you?
C: No… it just came up somewhere deep inside… but here, at this moment, I feel completely calm and steady… and fully safe too…
T: Very good, Madhu… with this effortless presence within you, let us move towards another important dimension of time… three… two… one

[PL3 / SE] Milda and Tabaka

(The client saw herself as a tribal girl. She gave the name herself: Milda.)
T: Where are you right now?
C: I am in the forest… I have come to hunt
T: Is anyone else with you?
C: No… I am alone
T: What you can see and feel around you right now… would you like to tell me about it?
C: It is spring… the mango trees are in blossom… the palash is in full flower… there is a river nearby… a cool breeze is blowing…
T: Okay… have you caught anything?
C: Yes… I have just caught two rabbits with a snare…
T: Do you want to hunt any more?
C: No… some strangers are coming this way… so I am hiding and watching them…
T: (after waiting for a while)… Have those strangers gone now?
C: They have… caught me… they want to take me away by force…
T: Are you afraid?
C: Yes, a little… but help is close… Tabaka is coming this way…
T: Tabaka?
C: He is my brother… my shadow… he has taken on the enemies… he is fighting…
T: Is everything alright now?
C: The enemies have gone… but Tabaka is wounded… and so am I…
(The client’s breathing was fast and the tension on her face was growing. I helped her relax and waited for a while until her breathing became deep and calm.)
T: If you feel like talking about the emotions you are going through right now… you may…
C: My breath is breaking… I feel my last moment is near… my head is in Tabaka’s lap… he keeps gazing at me
T: What do you feel when you look at Tabaka?
C: (a few seconds of silence) He looks like Tarun (the client’s husband’s name)… the same feeling… the same love…
T: Like Tarun…

C:…Yes, exactly like him…

T: Would you like to stay with this experience for a while?
C: My breath is breaking… Tabaka keeps crying… calling my name again and again… Milda… Milda

[LT] The Final Moment

T: In these last moments, would you like to say anything to Tabaka?
C: I have taken a promise from him… if not in this life, then in every life to come, he should be with me… stay close to me…
T: Life is ready to set out on a new journey… as I count from three to one… watch yourself being freed from the body (count down)
(At this moment of separation from her brother, the client had an Acute Abreaction.)
(A long pause. I stayed silent and waited for the client’s response.)

[PD] After Death

C: (on her own, after the pause)… my body is lying on the ground below… and my brother Tabaka is weeping bitterly… I am watching from the sky… everything like a film
T: How are you feeling at this moment?
C: Detached and transparent… but there is still a slight ache of being away from my brother…

[LBL] Dialogue with Higher Consciousness

T: Meeting and parting… life and death are part of our journey… and your consciousness has experienced this truth many times.
(The client was silent, as if still caught in some question.)
T: Has your consciousness got stuck on some question?
C: Yes… but at the same time an understanding is arising, that not every question has to have an answer… sometimes simply seeing an experience without giving it a meaning is enough…
T: Very good… just stay in that awareness which is wider than your experience.
(Pause)
T: Freedom from the limits of the body is an opportunity… an opportunity to converse with the divine consciousness present around you… ask that awareness… if a relationship has held deep love, protection and strong attachment, is it necessary to carry that old role into the next life as well?
(Pause)
C: I have the answer… it is not necessary…
T: Then what does come along?
(Silence)
C: The shadow of intense emotions sometimes leaves a deep imprint on consciousness…
T: You may ask the guiding field of consciousness the deepest question of your present life, the question tied to your greatest dilemma… what is it, after all… that stands like a permanent barrier in your married life?
(The client signalled agreement with her finger.)

C:…the stages we have passed through are not carried along with us… every life is a new journey… every new journey brings a new role… new relationships are not copies of the past… what had to happen… is what happened… that is what always happens… accept it just as it is…

T: Is this guidance helpful in untangling the confusion in your present life?
C: Yes, perhaps…
T: Anything else important that you would like to receive… it need not be in words… it need not be an experience… its simply being there is enough
(A look of deep peace on the client’s face, but no words. She stayed in this state for some time.)

[CL] Present Life: Her Husband

T: Carrying with you the divine guidance from the higher consciousness and the clarity it brought, let us return to the present life, as I count from three to one (count down)
T: The present life… and you are sharing a happy moment with your husband…
T: What are you feeling?
C: A deep sense of belonging…
T: And his role in this life?
C: My husband… my life partner
T: Now look at the old experiences on one side… and this relationship on the other.
(Silence for a while)
C: There is belonging in all of them.
T: And what is different?
C: Only the role is different…

[CL] Re-experiencing Intimacy

(I asked the client to imagine her husband coming close to her. This had always been the moment when she felt like pulling away.)
T: This is your own moment… completely safe… there is no need to say anything… what is free of inner conflict… what is auspicious… beautiful… that alone is right…
(Before going any further into this private space, I let the client stay with her own experience and emotions.)
(Pause)

[Integration / PHS]

T: Let whatever was in the old experiences remain there with respect. That relationship does not have to be erased, but the role of that time can be complete within that time. The relationship you have been given in this life can be allowed to be lived according to the needs, boundaries, intimacy and reality of this life.
(Silence for a while)
C: What was, has its own place.
C: What is, is different.
C: I can now see my husband in his role in this life, with ease.
C: What was is complete in its own place. What is may be lived just as it is. I can experience my present relationship in its present role.
(I kept these very words of the client as the PHS.)
(At closure, Madhu said she felt “very light”, and rated her intimacy-related distress at about 1/10.)
(With this, the session was formally closed.)
(After the session, Madhu said she felt “comfortable”, and then: “I don’t want to pull away.”)

5. Key Observations

  • A smile and “very safe” at the fair; “calm and warm” in the womb, and she recognised her father’s voice herself.
  • PL1: a familiar boy, “someone of my own”; after my question about the present life, she said, “He looks like my husband.” Tearful at his death; the grief eased after watching as a spectator.
  • PL2: “his eyes are exactly like Tarun’s”; water from his hands, “for the first time someone treated me like a human being”. In the PD, a pink sky and rainbows, “as if I have come back home”, but an “ache… like a splinter” of losing him.
  • PL3: very rich sensory detail; “he is my brother… my shadow”; Tabaka “looks like Tarun… the same feeling, the same love”. Acute Abreaction at the separation.
  • LBL: she signalled agreement with her finger (IMR agreed in advance), and the insight “not every question has to have an answer” arose on its own.

6. Engram Mapping and Inner State

Core Engram: Milda dies with her head in her brother Tabaka’s lap, taking his promise: “if not in this life, then in every life to come, he should be with me… stay close to me.” Visual: his gaze, the tears. Auditory: his calling, “Milda… Milda”. Kinesthetic: breath breaking, wounds. Emotion: grief of separation, with love and safety. Vow: this line seems to bind the relationship to the role of a protector-brother.

Echoes: In all three lives, a man who felt like “someone of my own” came as a protector and was lost, and each time she saw a glimpse of her husband in him.

Inner state: For Madhu, safety has a face. In childhood it was Papa’s, lifting her onto his shoulders, his voice heard in the womb. In regression, the same safety came as a friend like an elder brother, a protector, and her own brother. Emotional closeness is familiar ground for her. When it starts to become marital and physical, an old “protector and family” feeling seems to wake up, and she pulls back. The desire is there; it does not seem to turn towards her husband. All of this is my working hypothesis.

7. Trigger and Maintaining Loop

The moment closeness turns physical (Trigger) brings a sudden urge to pull away (Response), serving a need for safety and a familiar bond. She pulls back; intimacy stays incomplete; guilt follows, with the loneliness of telling no one, not even her husband; and the next time, the same moment brings the same response. The heaviest link, to me, is guilt: her husband’s patience may deepen it.

8. Competing Explanations

Present life: the deep bond with her father, or simply needing time after one year of marriage. Psychological: hesitation from upbringing; guilt itself keeping the loop going (a medical cause is less likely, as the doctor found nothing). Symbolic: the three lives may picture an inner conflict between safety and intimacy. PLRT: a protector-brother template and the promise across lives (CO). This session cannot settle which is right; all four may be true together.

9. Guidance Load: Moderate

The pre-natal entry, the spectator suggestion, the affect bridge (“Grief is a bridge”), the present-life scene and the intimacy imagery were all my instructions. In PL1, “it’s only a game” made light of her feeling, and the husband link came after my present-life question. In LBL, my statement and my “carry the old role” question hinted at an answer. The integration framework was mine, and her words came after it. What I did not suggest: her father’s voice, the names Milda and Tabaka, “my shadow”, the husband glimpse in PL2 and PL3, and “not every question has to have an answer”. The central LBL guidance came after an open question.

10. Outcome, Recommendations and Follow-Up

At closure she felt “very light” and rated her distress at 1/10. After the session she said she felt “comfortable”, and “I don’t want to pull away.” This is a session-level outcome; without follow-up it is not lasting change.

Recommendations: spend more time together; create a romantic atmosphere; open up more to each other; go out, just the two of you; don’t hold the thought of a blockage; in romantic moments, give no room to any other emotion.

Follow-Up: Not Documented yet. To check: has the urge to pull away changed, has intimacy become easier, has she been able to share this with her husband?

11. My Learning, Limitations and Questions

This case showed me the difference between love and the role through which love is lived. The form kept changing: friend, protector, brother, husband. The belonging stayed the same. The whole integration rested on one distinction: in this life, that person is not her brother; he is her husband. Her line “not every question has to have an answer” became a lesson for me too, and in PL1 I saw Disidentification and the affect bridge working together for the first time. The words at the end were hers, though they came right after my integration statement. I did not need to remove the old relationship; only to tell the two apart.

Limitations: regression material is subjective; its link to the present difficulty is a hypothesis; the father’s role is an observed theme, not established etiology; guidance was moderate; the husband’s perspective is not recorded; closure improvement is not long-term proof. The “ache” left in both PDs shows the imprint may not have fully dissolved.

Questions for the seniors:

  1. Was my PL1 question about a present-life connection appropriate, or should I have waited for the client to bring it up?
  2. How can an LBL question be kept more open, so the insight stays entirely the client’s own?
  3. She saw her husband in a brother-figure. How do I make sure integration does not strengthen “my husband is like a brother”?
  4. How far is it right to go with an intimacy rehearsal inside trance?
  5. Should the father thread have been worked on separately with the inner child, and would it help to involve the husband later, with her consent?

12. Epistemic Summary

FACT: married about a year; four sessions; doctor found no physical problem (client-reported). OBSERVATION: the urge to pull away; distress 9, 7, 1; the husband glimpse in all three lives; Acute Abreaction at the separation. ANALYSIS: safety linked to a protective male presence. INFERENCE: the father bond may contribute. HYPOTHESIS: the protector-brother template and promise may get in the way of present intimacy. SPECULATION: that they are truly the same soul. UNRESOLVED: long-term outcome; attraction versus desire.

Professional note: No diagnosis is given. Past-life material is recorded as the client’s experience, not as fact. A documented follow-up is needed to complete this case.

Therapist’s Note

The name of the relationship kept changing.
Friend, protector, brother… and this time, husband.
What never changed was the belonging.
This case taught me that old love does not have to be erased.
It only has to be allowed to stay in its own place,
so that today’s relationship can be lived as today’s.

Follow up report

I followed up with the client by phone ten days after the session. When I asked what had changed in her life since the session, she thanked me and said that the biggest obstacle of her life had been removed, that the guilt had gone, and that they could now live a normal married life. These are the client’s own words, translated from Hindi.

10 Likes

It’s tricky- I take a 50-50 approach on that, may be or may be not. It would depend on the therapist and the experience entirely. You could have waited and may be let her stay in the moment to reach that awareness on her own. But you guided her very well and it came out beautifully. So I feel if the outcome is positive then it’s fine. In this case it worked.

In LBL, we don’t suggest a presence of guide or light or anything similar. Simply keep it open by asking the client to remain there and ask- what they notice? What draws their attention and what are they experiencing? It’s still serves the purpose of engaging but at the same time giving em the chance to explore their own learnings and understandings.

Again a complex issue- you could ask her - what does that experience trying to tell you? What qualities you felt during that experience can be learned in connection to your present life? And depending on her answer you guided her. May be there are some qualities she felt during that experience like safety, protection and safeguarding. And she might be trying to find meaning to all that in her present life.

I’m not a psychiatrist but I would just lay the foundation of awareness that her husband is her husband in the present life and she can decide what closeness feels right to her. I guess that should be her choice.

Yes! Again, whatever experience she had, it all had a meaning to her and you could have explore by asking her about- what feelings/emotions she had from the moment? What is she missing in her life about the moment and her father? And then inner child healing might have done.

Mostly women seek some kinda father figure in their husbands, knowingly or unknowingly. So inner child healing might have brought her some clarity and you could have brought the husband issue later after cleaning the residue.

Thank you @satishsinghthakur Satish Ji for conducting a thoroughly deep case. You have refined your skills in no time and it’s getting better and better with each case. I again liked the crisp and categorized presentation of the case report. You built up the interest from the beginning and that kept the story going smooth and in flow. I loved reading it, and the questions at the end for seniors are very precise. That shows the importance and depth of your work and hunger to learn and grow :cherry_blossom::cherry_blossom: beautiful!! I tried to answer the questions with my limited knowledge on the subject. I may be right or wrong but I’m me :wink: still under construction :construction: :smiley::smiley:

ek sher :lion: pesh-eh-Khidmat hai-

“मंजिले उन्ही को मिलती है जिनके सपनों में जान होती है,
पंखों से कुछ नहीं होता हौसलों से उड़ान होती है।”

7 Likes

आभार से आगे — सीखने की यात्रा :seedling:

Thank you so much, Harmeet Ji, for taking the time to engage with each of my questions so thoughtfully. आपके उत्तरों में मुझे सिर्फ answers नहीं, बल्कि “how to think as a therapist” सीखने को मिला।

सबसे अधिक जो बात मेरे साथ रह गई, वह है—“facilitate awareness, rather than direct awareness.”
PL1 के आपके उत्तर ने मुझे यह देखने का अवसर दिया कि therapist की भूमिका कितनी सूक्ष्म है—कहां प्रश्न करना है और कहां ठहर जाना है, ताकि client स्वयं उस awareness तक पहुंच सके।

LBL पर आपकी बात भी मेरे लिए बहुत महत्वपूर्ण learning है। “Space open रखना”—बिना guide, light या किसी predetermined presence को introduce किए—client को अपनी consciousness में स्वयं explore करने की स्वतंत्रता देता है। यहीं शायद enquiry और suggestion के बीच की महीन रेखा है।

Husband–brother experience पर आपका perspective मेरे लिए विशेष रूप से valuable रहा। मैंने महसूस किया कि किसी experience को तुरंत कोई meaning दे देना integration नहीं है। बेहतर प्रश्न शायद यह है—
“यह अनुभव आपको क्या बताने की कोशिश कर रहा है?”
और फिर client को अपने meaning तक पहुंचने देना।

Intimacy rehearsal और father thread पर आपकी बात ने एक और महत्वपूर्ण बात सिखाई—पहले emotional residue को समझना, फिर relationship को interpret करना। Inner-child work के माध्यम से उस unmet need को explore करना शायद अधिक सुरक्षित और meaningful रास्ता हो सकता है।

मेरे लिए इस पूरे feedback का सार शायद यही है:

Therapist को हमेशा यह जानना जरूरी नहीं कि client को कहां पहुंचाना है;
उसे इतना जरूर जानना चाहिए कि client को स्वयं देखने के लिए कितना space देना है।

और शायद यही “नियंत्रण से सहयात्रा” की ओर बढ़ना है।

आपने अपने जवाब में लिखा—“I may be right or wrong… still under construction.”
मुझे यह पंक्ति बहुत पसंद आई। क्योंकि शायद हम सभी, चाहे कितने भी cases कर लें, “अभी निर्माणाधीन” ही रहते हैं। हर case हमारे भीतर के therapist को थोड़ा और refine करता है।

आपके सुंदर sher के लिए भी विशेष आभार।
हौसला उड़ान देता है, लेकिन सही दिशा हमें यात्रा सिखाती है।

आपके feedback को मैं सिर्फ appreciation की तरह नहीं, बल्कि अपनी अगले sessions के लिए एक learning compass की तरह साथ ले जा रहा हूं।

दिल से धन्यवाद, Harmeet Ji. :cherry_blossom:

5 Likes

Anytime!! You are most welcome Satish Ji. I like reading your case report and comments on the forum. You go deep to understand behind the scenes and it already started to reflect in your cases. And yes we all are under construction :smiley: life निरंतर सीखने और समझने की यात्रा है। हर दिन हम नया सीखते हैं चाहे अनचाहे and जाने अनजाने। I like that you crave for feedback and take it very seriously and positively. I’m not a pro but I also like to understand from a different aspect. Everyone has their own interpretation. जितना मुझे पता है I try to write if someone is asking or not! I’m genetically programmed to answer as my mom is from उत्तर प्रदेश :smiley: so naturally I have all the उत्तर :wink:!

5 Likes

Thank you so much, Harmeet Ji. :folded_hands:

Your words genuinely mean a lot to me. I think my curiosity to go “behind the scenes” is actually a way of learning to look beyond the obvious—and feedback like yours helps me sharpen that lens.

And yes, we are all under construction! :blush: शायद यही खूबसूरती है कि construction कभी पूरी नहीं होती—life keeps adding new layers of learning, unlearning and understanding.

I also truly value your perspective because, as you rightly said, everyone has their own interpretation. Sometimes another person’s lens helps us see something in our own work that we were too close to notice.

And now that I know you are genetically programmed to answer because of your UP connection… I’ll have to be careful before asking a question! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:
कहीं एक सवाल के बदले पूरे उत्तर प्रदेश का उत्तर न मिल जाए! :joy:

Grateful to have seniors and fellow learners like you on this journey. :folded_hands:
Still under construction… but happily so. :seedling:

5 Likes

Haha! Life is interesting with lil bit of humour. Otherwise therapy is too heavy.

I’m privileged and blessed to be walking this path with all my fellow therapists. This community is ज्ञान का भंडार and everyone is an expert on something or the other. Sometimes I feel I might have done some good deeds to be a part of PLRT. How did I get so lucky :four_leaf_clover:

5 Likes

एक सवाल पूछकर मुझे रोकना मुश्किल है… आपने उत्तर मांगा था पर मैंने क्षेत्रफल बढ़ा दिया :smiley:

4 Likes

A very beautifully documented and deeply reflective case, Satish Ji . I appreciated how you have clearly distinguished observation, analysis and hypothesis. That makes the case both insightful and grounded.

The recurring theme of safety, belonging, protection and changing relational roles is very interesting. I particularly loved the integration: “What was is complete in its own place. What is may be lived just as it is.” It feels like the real essence of the session was not to erase the old bond, but to help the client differentiate the emotional imprint from the role of the relationship in the present life.

One gentle reflection that came to me was around the moments where the husband connection was explored through therapist-led questions. Perhaps keeping those questions slightly more open could allow the client’s own meaning to emerge even more organically.

I also found the father–safety thread quite significant and would be curious to see whether further exploration of this dimension brings additional clarity.

Overall, a very sensitive case report, and I truly appreciate your openness in sharing not only what worked, but also your own limitations and questions as a therapist. That self-reflection itself is a valuable part of the learning. :folded_hands::cherry_blossom:

4 Likes

Thank you so much for this thoughtful reflection priyanka ji. :folded_hands:

Your observation about keeping the questions more open really stayed with me. Facilitation और interpretation के बीच की fine line को और consciously hold करना है—so that the client’s meaning emerges rather than being shaped by mine.

The father–safety thread is also something I would like to explore more deeply in future work.

I truly value feedback that helps me look at the same case through another lens. Sometimes the most valuable learning comes not from what we concluded, but from what we realise we could have explored differently.

Grateful for your generous perspective. :folded_hands::cherry_blossom:

4 Likes

The Deep love and respect you have for this therapy is so palpable. I am honoured to be in the same batch as you!

5 Likes

Oh man I don’t know why the sher made me cry! I deeply value your presence and guidance for all of us, Harmeet!

5 Likes

Aww! That’s so sweet! It made my day :heart: I love being with you all and if my words bring any smile or encouragement then I feel so much loved and full of gratitude for getting back the love and support :heart: together forever :heart::cherry_blossom::cherry_blossom:

5 Likes

Thanks diya ji.. It means a lot for me :waving_hand:

4 Likes

:lion: sher can make anyone cry :sweat_smile: actual or poetic :joy::joy: sorry my laughing meter is working overtime :sweat_smile: blame it on the moon :crescent_moon:

4 Likes

Lastly, and I could be completely wrong, I didn’t see a mention of guilt anywhere in her account of any life. I may have missed it, but I didn’t find it mentioned in her experience or her account of her memories, and to Tabaka either. In the LBL, I think we can gain clarity on it with more direct questions about the dilemma itself. I felt that her dilemma was more about a looming sense of loss of the person closest to her. I think a couple of direct questions about her feelings, her dilemma and where she felt it in her body would help to understand. She could be indeed feeling guilty of the intimacy, but I would not want to assume that from my end. I would like to get that data from her, and clarify if that comes as a proposition to my mind as a therapist. Here, I feel I need not hesitate to ask her questions unless she refuses to share that information or expresses discomfort. To my mind, she seemed very comfortable in sharing the data. But the questions seemed too abstract to my mind. This process would be important to me despite of the outcome because I would want to know how to proceed with clarity for someone who has similar issues in the future. So I would suggest asking direct questions here such as: 1. What would you think was the dilemma or the trigger 2. Resolution- We could reframe the scenario of her PL3 where she asks her brother to come again and again, creating a kind of loop for him and her. I feel that could be the issue. They are both not completely free of each other. So she could release both of them from this cycle of rebirth in this dynamic by setting him free. And thereafter, imagining her present relationship as a fresh start, which she did from your suggestions as well. Just to reiterate, this was a phenomenal effort from your end. And goes on to show your level of ethics and sensitivity as a therapist, specially towards a female client. You handled this very gracefully and ethically. I would just suggest that you can absolutely probe further unless there is hesitation on the part of the client. And ofcourse if there is anything else I can share my perspective as a woman, I would be happy to. Thanks for sharing this case. More power to you.

3 Likes
  1. Intimacy rehearsal in trance: I would suggest keep taking consent of the client in their waking state, their trance state and go ahead with wherever they are leading you. Its important to leave our own fears, hesitations and judgement at the door. So perhaps the thought is coming from our own sense of hesitation, which is natural and normal. And beautifully handled by you. So in my view, even if the client is taking us to a very intricate dialogue on intimacy, we can follow their lead. 4. Father memory: I did not understand what you meant by, working on the father memory. I thought she has the father memory as a feeling of safety and protection. I didn’t feel there was something to be worked on. Pls do reply if I missed something.
3 Likes

Satish ji, beautiful case and closure. Thanks for sharing. I have a few observations I would like to share, and I would also like to engage with some of your questions as follows: 1. I thought the trigger was intimacy because of the way she had experienced loss in each LT with the person she felt closest to, or had the protector role in her life 2. Intimacy dynamic in relationships: I personally feel there need not be hesitation on our part in thinking of SP relationships and the intimacy involved, and possible overlaps or imprints that could suggest brotherliness. I think all bonds at the soul level are interchangeable, and sexual intimacy is just another experience of the soul of several emotions, and is stored as such. There would not ideally be a kind of clash between the various feelings in intimacy in different bonds. I think sexual boundaries in social bonds are socially defined, and it would not make a difference to the soul. So the changing social nature of relationships would not affect the clients ability to be intimate with their husband in a sexual way. I think the fact that you wanted to think about it and discuss it is a sign of an ethical and professional therapist.

3 Likes

Abhiruchi Ji, looks like you have launched a full-scale bombardment of observations today! :blush: And I must say, some of these deserve more than a quick reply.

Thank you for engaging with the case so deeply. Let me share a few thoughts from my side as well.

1. On Intimacy as the Possible Trigger

I find your observation interesting. In fact, I would look at intimacy and the fear of losing an intimate bond as two closely connected dimensions here.

Across all three lifetimes, the client experienced a deep emotional connection with someone who offered protection, belonging or unconditional support, followed by separation and loss.

However, I would still keep the exact trigger open. Was it intimacy itself, the fear of losing someone deeply loved, or an unconscious association between intimacy and a familiar protective relationship? I think these possibilities deserve separate exploration.

2. On Soul-Level Relationships and Intimacy

I appreciate your perspective that relationships and their roles may change across lifetimes, while emotional imprints may continue.

My own concern was not about judging the nature of those relationships through present-life social definitions. It was about understanding the client’s subjective experience and whether the brother-protector association was somehow becoming active at the threshold of marital intimacy.

I agree that we should follow the client’s experience without imposing our own social conditioning. At the same time, I would distinguish between allowing the client to explore freely and actively directing the exploration. Consent and emotional comfort remain central.

3. On the Father Memory

Here, I would like to add something to your observation.

The father appears in two significant experiences: the childhood happy moment at the fair, where she feels completely safe on his shoulders, and the pre-natal experience, where she independently recognises his voice and feels his closeness.

To me, these are two meaningful observations, not necessarily just incidental memories.

I agree that there was no obvious distress in these experiences. But I wonder whether the strong father-daughter bond could have offered another dimension to understanding her association between emotional safety, protection and intimacy.

Perhaps exploring this thread further during induction or inner-child work could have revealed something additional. I would not call it an unresolved wound, but a potentially important area that deserved more exploration.

4. On Guilt and LBL

I agree with your distinction between an observed emotion and a therapist’s hypothesis. Guilt was clearly present in her current-life account, but I could not establish it as the underlying emotion in all three regression narratives.

Your suggestion of asking more direct questions in LBL is valuable. I would particularly like to explore what exactly she felt was unresolved, where she experienced the dilemma emotionally, and whether the promise made to Tabaka was still carrying some emotional weight.

Your idea of releasing both individuals from that recurring relational cycle is interesting. I would, however, prefer to let the client’s own understanding and readiness guide such an intervention rather than introduce the release as a predetermined resolution.

One final thought

Perhaps the most important distinction emerging from this case is between the continuity of emotional belonging and the changing roles of relationships.

The client herself arrived at the insight: “There is belonging in all of them. Only the role is different.”

For me, that became the central point of integration. We did not need to deny the emotional significance of the earlier experiences; we needed to help her experience her present relationship in its present role.

And interestingly, in the ten-day follow-up, she reported that the guilt had gone and that they could now live a normal married life. Of course, I would still distinguish her reported improvement from independently established long-term outcomes.

Abhiruchi JI, I genuinely value this exchange. I may not agree with every interpretation, but that is precisely what makes this discussion worthwhile. Your observations have helped me look at some parts of my own process again.

And yes, I would certainly welcome your perspective as a woman. There is always another dimension we can learn from.

Thank you for the thoughtful engagement. :folded_hands:

2 Likes

How beautiful! :clap: That’s where real growth happens, when we can welcome feedback, respect differing perspectives, and agree to disagree without closing the door to learning.

Perfect! I feel it’s useful to welcome and observe things from different perspectives, it offers an opportunity to see through someone else’s lenses. That’s the real growth. You are so very kind @satishsinghthakur Satish Ji!

2 Likes

Harmeet Ji, beautifully expressed! :folded_hands:

I think you have touched upon something much deeper here.

मेरे लिए इस पूरे संवाद का सार शायद यही है कि understanding someone doesn’t necessarily mean agreeing with them. It means being willing to step outside our own frame of reference and look at the same reality through another person’s lens.

Abhiruchi’s observations, your response and this subsequent exchange have added different dimensions to the same exploration.

I believe learning begins when we stop treating our perspectives as conclusions and start treating them as possibilities.

कभी-कभी दूसरे की बात हमें सहमत नहीं करती, लेकिन अपने भीतर कुछ और गहराई से देखने के लिए जरूर प्रेरित करती है।

And perhaps, the real purpose of dialogue is not to change someone’s mind, but to expand the space in which both minds can explore.

एक शेर याद आ रहा है:

वो मुतमईन है कि पत्थर पिघल नहीं सकता,
मैं बेकरार हूँ आवाज़ में असर के लिए।

Perhaps that is the beauty of a meaningful dialogue. One may remain convinced, the other may continue exploring, but neither should lose the willingness to listen.

After all, growth is not always about changing our conclusions; sometimes, it is simply about expanding our capacity to understand.

Thank you, Harmeet Ji, for adding another beautiful dimension to this conversation. :folded_hands:

2 Likes